Funnybook Babylon

May 20, 2013

Off Topic: No More Butlers

Filed under: Blurbs — Jamaal Thomas @ 5:30 pm

 

I know that you shouldn’t judge a movie by its trailer, but God, I hate the trailer for The Butler. It wraps all of the problematic bits about Hollywood’s approach to race and history in a single horrifying package. The Butler is the new film from Lee Daniels (director of Shadowboxer, Precious and last year’s Paperboy), adapted from a Washington Post article by Wil Haygood about Eugene Allen, a man who served as a butler for eight American Presidents. You should read Haygood’s article, it’s a pretty fun human interest piece. I would love to watch a movie about Allen’s life, especially one that featured Forest Whitaker, David Oyewolo and even Oprah Winfrey (she’s always been pretty good when she puts her mind to it). After watching the trailer, I suspect that I will be disappointed. The trailer for the Butler is aggressively bland. it suggests that the film will be a ‘prestige’, award grubbing film that will remind me of all of the problems with the way major studio films approach race, history and family.

Forest Whitaker, patiently waiting for his nominations.

The most significant problem is that the narrative suggested by the trailer is incredibly dull. I’d be interested in the story of a man who overcomes a childhood in the Jim Crow South to become a butler to Presidents that focused on his journey and struggles. But there are too many moments in this trailer when someone is talking to (or for) Whitaker or he’s smiling beatifically. We don’t hear enough of his voice or perspective. The parade of amusingly miscast Presidents is fine, but I care less about his marginal impact on their views on race than about how he maintained a healthy relationship with his wife despite the demanding hours of his profession or how his experience as a sharecropper informed his parenting. I hope that we’ll see more of the latter, but the trailer doesn’t look too promising.

The trailer’s banal depiction of the relationship between father and son would have been tolerable if the son’s evolution from Freedom Rider to Black Panther and the generational conflict that results from that transformation wasn’t so disappointing. I have no doubt that real people have had the experience depicted in the film, but I’d be far more interested in a narrative that embraced the complexity and fascinating paradoxes of the movement and that didn’t characterize the distinctions between the two arms of the civil rights movement as a generation gap. There were plenty of older folk (including veterans of the civil rights movement) that sympathized with (or embraced) the radicals. Similarly, there were plenty of Panthers (and members of other ‘radical’ groups) that had no experience in the movement, and were simply radicalized by being a black person in mid-century. The trailer suggests that the Butler will embrace the traditional Hollywood approach to Civil Rights that embraces the standard consensus we all learn in middle school and ignores the diversity within the movement and the community. Instead of showing us something new, it’s a highlight reel of all the things that mainstream America remembers re: the African American community. It’s a wasted opportunity.

The same could be said of the trailer’s depiction of Presidents from the second half of the twentieth century. These were the first Presidents of the television era, and it would be fun to see a look at the way that their behavior reinforces and/or confounds conventional wisdom. The trailer shows us glimpses of every President from Eisenhower (Robin Williams) to Nixon (John Cusack) (with a quick appearance by Reagan (Alan Rickman)) with an emphasis on Kennedy (James Marsden).

I wanted the trailer to show us a more nuanced Kennedy than we were accustomed to seeing in popular culture – a man struggling with his appetites, legacy and mixed feelings about civil rights and the Cold War. Maybe we’ll see that in the film, but the bits in the trailer don’t look very promising (that whole ‘you helped me understand black people’ bit was cringeworthy). The segments with the other Presidents felt like excerpts from SNL skits (the hilarious casting choices don’t help – seriously, Robin Williams as Dwight Eisenhower?).

This trailer reminds me of all of the films about black life and culture that never see the big screen. I want more stories about notable figures, entrepreneurs and leaders of color. There aren’t enough films about the African American community that are set after the 1960’s that aren’t about drugs or violence.

Maybe I’m wrong. Maybe the trailer fails to capture the nuance of the film. It’s just so bad that I can’t imagine setting aside the time (or spending the money) to give it a chance.

5 Comments »

  1. Hey, got here from your tumblr. . . kind of . . . I really like your stuff but the Funnybook Babylon link on your tumblr is broken because of a minor typo and I thought I would let you know

    Comment by Quia nonnunquam — June 1, 2013 @ 3:37 pm

  2. Thanks so much for the note! The tumblr link is fixed.

    Comment by Jamaal Thomas — June 1, 2013 @ 10:56 pm

  3. […] (originally posted 5/20/13 on Funnybook Babylon) […]

    Pingback by Off Topic: No More Butlers — June 28, 2013 @ 10:32 am

  4. The most frequent query in relation to meeting a girl for sex is: Hookup or escort ladies or internet dating sites [url=https://wikihookup.com/st-cloud-mn-hookups]https://wikihookup.com/st-cloud-mn-hookups[/url] It has been one of the most requested issue within the on the internet mature courting world for many years. And the answer will be: There may be not one appropriate response. It genuinely is dependent upon how you apply the online and which kind of women you need to speak to and speak with. You will find both dating sites and hookups, and you can use either one of these to fulfill a girl for sex.

    Online dating sites are getting to be extremely popular over the years due to the fact there are millions of folks utilizing online dating solutions. It really is a very fantastic way to meet up with other individuals. All you have to do is generate a free account with the website you select and write down all of the things that you are interested in in a date or possibly a mate. Then you certainly simply use the internet and search for females who match your information. You could even locate some pretty gorgeous ladies!

    Hookups is another problem altogether. Dating apps were actually just like major a hit just some time ago, nevertheless they gained in reputation even faster. These apps are like dating sites, besides they provide one gentlemen use of countless women who have user profiles. They are designed to be utilized by a certain group of people-low-charge [url=http://musicroworg.ning.com/profile/RoyIFinkbeiner]go to my site[/url] extremely focused buyers. These apps are an easy way to find a hookup since normally the pricing is reduced and also the coverage is substantial.

    The problem using these apps is the fact that some females are employing those to work cons. Many of the apps accessible are made to behave like they may be internet dating, but are actually bots programmed by online hackers to attempt to solicit sexual activity from guys. Due to the fact several of these apps derive from innovative computer programs, the predators know specifically how to make the connection seem to be harmless. So, if you’re a man trying to find hookups, you need to consider, “Are these apps awful?”

    Escorts are licensed to pick up gentlemen, and so they operate in sizeable urban places. The Web made it quite simple to focus on ladies who are trying to find everyday sex. The only thing you really have to do is create a information, put in a photograph, and attach a lot of is and misinformation concerning your life. The greater number of details you include, the much more likely this is basically the escorts you talk to will consider you’re intent on meeting someone.

    To be honest, there are lots of sincere, diligent escorts searching for everyday gender online. Males just like you and me who wish to create a fast hookup should not be frightened of nearing these girls. Actually, approaching them is more to the stage. In fact, you don’t really be prepared to engage a attorney to negotiate an agreement, do you? Having said that, it’s always a smart idea to use a basic idea of what an escort is, and how they function.

    The web is loaded with tales of hookups eliminated poor. Even so, it is possible to avoid this by keeping your user profile as easy as you possibly can [url=https://disqus.com/by/anydarvin/]https://disqus.com/by/anydarvin/[/url] Be sure you note you are an escort, not just a hookup, and that you only want sexual activity. Escorts seeking casual sexual intercourse will not be the best men and women to pursue this type of relationship.

    Last but not least, escorts seeking informal sex must also recognize that they may hookup with some other females who want the same thing as them. This is actually the best thing, mainly because it means they won’t have to constantly rest regarding their goals. It’s significant to understand that not every ladies want to sleeping with every person they fulfill. It’s alright in order to mix it up and try to come up with a excellent link.

    Comment by Peterwhalm — July 21, 2021 @ 5:32 pm

  5. Improve your keyboard font on Instagram to help make your photographs seem much better. It works in most software: Instinct, Instagram, Whatsapp etc [url=https://fontsprokeyboard.com/popular-dafont-fonts]https://fontsprokeyboard.com/popular-dafont-fonts[/url] This instagram key pad tweak is a cost-free instagram key-board deal. The typefaces operate everywhere in virtually any application also. Just set up the application and permit the key pad alter your keyboard settings.

    Use instagram typefaces electrical generator to create gorgeous fonts instantly. It’s a straightforward solution for individuals that aren’t great at designing and you should not have enough time to try complex styles and fashions. Instagram typefaces generator allows you to choose from a number of fonts immediately. Take advantage of the useful resource to decide on your favourite size and shape then receive the font set up on instagram. You can modify your instagram written text by using this instagram typefaces electrical generator. Instagram typefaces are typically located on internet so you can get the trendy font you want for instagram.

    Instagram key pad is one of the most liked and many applied instagram equipment. Each and every end user around the social websites foundation uses it in a different way [url=https://apps.apple.com/app/id1503238062]find here[/url] Even so, this excellent key pad causes it to be much more intriquing, notable and simpler to use for users. There are lots of things you can do with this particular specific typefaces keyboard in the mobile app and so that you can increase its energy, here is a selection of handful of tips.

    Receive the wanted font for instagram in the instagram typefaces art gallery. There are a number of fonts available for cost-free in the instagram fonts gallery. You are able to opt for any one of them based on your decision and as outlined by your need. Even so, you ought to continue to keep one thing in your mind. When picking any of the typefaces, you should always opt for the ones that are cost free as those who are paid are of no use within making your profile appealing.

    Consumption of instagram fonts within each and every app and also in all applications like Facebook and twitter is greatly growing. Many individuals enjoy to use this sort of computer keyboard for them to make their user profiles more interesting. The key reason why most people favor instagram is its lively and unique appearance. Everybody feels as though submitting some thing distinctive on instagram. So as to make your profile more exclusive, you can consider to utilize a number of the particular fonts within every iphone app.

    It is possible to change your key pad fonts manually by downloading them online or you can even get them manually set up on your personal computer by surfing around various websites supplying typeface fonts without charge. There are many of websites available that offer free typefaces to use in all of the programs which include instagram. In this way, you are able to improve your key-board typefaces anytime and anywhere you want. These typefaces are incredibly easy to mount on your personal computer and in many cases you may download it straight from a particular internet site.

    Setting up fonts on your personal computer is easy. Just click on the typeface typefaces and the proper page will open. There you can choose the type and scale of the typeface that you simply prefer to use in the apps. Most of the font keyboards permits the consumer to utilize only one sort of typeface in the software along with the consumer could also alter them as often he/she wants.

    Keyboard is a superb tool that lets you produce distinctive and appealing graphics, text messages and artwork. If you are an instagram customer, you need to have noticed the multitude of pictures uploaded by diverse consumers. Everybody employs instagram for various functions. Nevertheless, none is aware of the significance of instagram typefaces. So, if you would like have more interest and produce remarkable pictures with instagram, alter your key-board typeface throughout the instagram app and saving time and funds.

    Comment by WilliamHam — July 23, 2021 @ 11:54 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

Powered by WordPress